Locked History Attachments

Diff for "StatistFallacies/CollectiveWill"

Differences between revisions 1 and 2
Revision 1 as of 2012-04-18 18:58:06
Size: 520
Editor: DavidRobins
Comment:
Revision 2 as of 2012-04-18 18:59:07
Size: 553
Editor: DavidRobins
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 7: Line 7:
A group of people is just that--a group of people. There is no such thing as "collective will." Only individuals take action. The government is nothing more than a collection of people who hold a self-appointed monopoly on force. A nation is nothing more than a group of people who live in a geographic area and have a group of thugs telling them what to do. ([[DV]]) A group of people is just that—a group of people. There is no such thing as "collective will." Only individuals take action. The government is nothing more than a collection of people who hold a self-appointed monopoly on force. A nation is nothing more than a group of people who live in a geographic area and have a group of thugs telling them what to do. ([[DV]])

Related: ../TheStateIsUs

Fallacy:

It is asserted that "we all" create and enforce laws; that it is "the nation" or "society" that wills it, etc.

Response:

A group of people is just that—a group of people. There is no such thing as "collective will." Only individuals take action. The government is nothing more than a collection of people who hold a self-appointed monopoly on force. A nation is nothing more than a group of people who live in a geographic area and have a group of thugs telling them what to do. (DV)

Related: ../TheStateIsUs