Revision 2 as of 2012-04-18 23:18:28

Clear message
Locked History Attachments

StatistFallacies/MightMakesRight

Fallacy:

There are variants of this one, but it comes down to "The state is right to tax you (etc.) because it can."

Response:

Understand the difference between power and right. The state may have the power to infringe on individual rights; but it does not have the right to do it. Rights do not physically protect themselves. A chained slave has the right to liberty, but it is presently infringed by the one who claims to own him. If able, he has the right to attempt escape; if freed, he is not rightly property of his claimed owner, and has a perfect right to run away, or, if necessary to free himself, use force to defend his infringed rights so that he may again exercise his right to liberty.

Similarly, if a man's wallet is stolen, it is still his rightful property; but he does not have the power to control it (it is not in his possession). Since it is his property, he has the right to use necessary force to take it back from the thief.

Related: ../Wouldn'tWarlordsTakeOver.